Category: Criterion and Boutique

Edition comparisons for Criterion and boutique-label films.

  • Raging Bull Criterion 4K vs. Blu-ray and Where to Find the Commentaries

    I’d buy the standalone Criterion Blu-ray of Raging Bull if I mostly wanted the commentaries. The 4K combo makes more sense if you also have a UHD player and want the HDR presentation of Michael Chapman’s black-and-white photography.

    Two discs in the 4K set

    Criterion’s U.S. 4K combo includes an HDR UHD disc of the film and a Blu-ray with the film and extras. The standalone Criterion Blu-ray is a one-disc edition. Both list the Scorsese-approved 4K master, so the words “4K master” on their own tell you very little about which disc will arrive.

    Black-and-white Raging Bull Criterion artwork framed by red boxing-ring ropes.
    Raging Bull 4K graphic from my Pinterest series.

    Which commentary to start with

    Pick Martin Scorsese and Thelma Schoonmaker for the director and editor’s perspective. The second track brings in cinematographer Michael Chapman and other collaborators. The third pairs Jake La Motta’s perspective with those of screenwriters Mardik Martin and Paul Schrader. If you’d rather watch a making-of program first, look for Fight Night on the Blu-ray.

    How to check a used copy

    The U.S. Criterion 4K combo’s UPC is 715515274210. Ask for both discs in the same photo, especially if the seller only shows the cover. For a gift, check which player the recipient already uses. The included Blu-ray gives them a disc they can watch now if a UHD player is still on their wishlist.

    Compare Criterion’s Raging Bull editions · Check the two-disc edition by UPC

    For another Scorsese release, see After Hours on Criterion 4K and Blu-ray.

  • Videodrome Criterion 4K vs. Blu-ray and Which Has the Unrated Cut

    If you want the unrated cut of Videodrome, Criterion’s regular Blu-ray already gives you that version. I’d choose the 4K combo for the Dolby Vision presentation or to keep a playable Blu-ray around while upgrading my setup.

    What comes in the Criterion 4K combo

    The U.S. combo has two discs. The 4K UHD disc presents the restored unrated film in Dolby Vision. The included Blu-ray carries the film and the supplements, so a standard Blu-ray player can play that disc. Criterion sells a separate one-disc Blu-ray with the unrated restoration, too.

    Videodrome Criterion case artwork in a green television-themed graphic marked 4K UHD plus Blu-ray.
    Videodrome 4K graphic from my Pinterest series.

    Which extras would I watch first?

    Start with Forging the New Flesh if you’re curious about the practical effects. Then try the Cronenberg and Mark Irwin commentary for the filmmaking side, or the James Woods and Deborah Harry track for the cast’s perspective. The set also includes Camera, Cronenberg’s short film, and a supplement with material from the film’s broadcasts.

    What I’d check in a used listing

    Ask for a photo of both disc labels. A used listing can mention a 4K restoration and still contain only the standard Blu-ray. For the U.S. Criterion combo, match the UPC 715515287715. If you’re importing the set for the extras, check whether your player can read the companion Blu-ray.

    Compare Criterion’s Videodrome editions · Check the UPC on Movies Unlimited

    More disc guides from Kay’s Finds & Designs include Mulholland Dr. on Criterion 4K and Blu-ray region codes.

  • The Silence of the Lambs Criterion 4K vs. Kino Lorber 4K

    If I already had Kino Lorber’s U.S. 4K of The Silence of the Lambs, I’d consider Criterion mainly for its supplements. Both labels list Dolby Vision on their respective UHD releases, so I’d look at which commentary and interviews I want before deciding to buy the movie again.

    The three-disc Criterion edition

    Criterion’s 2026 U.S. combo includes one UHD disc and two Blu-rays. The label lists a 1994 commentary with Jonathan Demme, Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins, Ted Tally, and John Douglas, plus a later interview with Demme and Foster. For someone who collects the filmmakers’ audio commentaries, the listed 1994 track is a detail worth checking.

    White case with red and black artwork for The Silence of the Lambs on a wooden table.
    Criterion edition illustration from my Pinterest series.

    The two-disc Kino Lorber edition

    Kino’s 30th-anniversary set includes the UHD and a Blu-ray. Its supplement list includes the original 1991 making-of featurette. Before upgrading, compare the two publishers’ actual supplement lists with the edition you already own and check which extras you’re likely to watch.

    Pick the label on the listing

    Select the U.S. Criterion 4K or Kino Lorber 4K by label and disc count. The same film artwork can show up with DVD, Blu-ray, UHD, and imported formats. I’d confirm the format in the selected option before ordering.

    Check the Amazon edition

    I may earn a commission if you buy through this Amazon link.

    Check the 2026 Criterion three-disc 4K combo on Amazon

    Sources

    Criterion’s The Silence of the Lambs edition specifications

    Kino Lorber’s 30th-anniversary UHD edition

  • Citizen Kane Criterion 4K Disc Count and Used Copy Checklist

    The first thing I’d check on a secondhand Citizen Kane Criterion set is the disc count. The UHD combo should have four discs. The standalone Criterion Blu-ray set has three. If a listing just says “Criterion 4K restoration,” confirm which edition the seller actually has.

    What comes inside the UHD combo

    Criterion lists one UHD disc of the film in Dolby Vision HDR and three standard Blu-rays with the film and supplements. The package includes multiple commentaries and material on the film’s special effects. If the historical context is why you’re buying it, check which supplemental discs are included before ordering.

    Citizen Kane Criterion 4K combo graphic with the letter K on a black cover.
    Citizen Kane 4K combo graphic from my Pinterest series.

    Why collectors ask about Blu-ray disc one

    Criterion reported a contrast problem on Blu-ray disc one from the first manufacturing run. The publisher says corrected stock was available as of January 19, 2022. If you’re considering an early used set, ask whether that Blu-ray was replaced or whether the seller knows which pressing it is.

    Which one I’d pick

    I’d compare the Blu-ray price first if I only use a Blu-ray player and want the supplements. I’d buy the four-disc set for the Dolby Vision UHD presentation on compatible equipment. On used listings, clear disc photos and a straightforward description matter more to me than a tidy front cover.

    Check the Amazon edition

    I may earn a commission if you buy through this Amazon link.

    Check the four-disc Citizen Kane 4K combo on Amazon

    Sources

    Criterion’s Citizen Kane editions and disc correction

  • Seven Samurai Criterion 4K vs. Blu-ray and the Framing Difference

    I’d buy the Criterion Seven Samurai 4K set if I wanted Kurosawa’s film on UHD and already had a compatible player. The biggest detail to check when comparing listings is that even the two formats inside the same case have slightly different framing specifications.

    Which disc has which framing

    Criterion lists the UHD presentation at 1.37:1 and the standard Blu-ray presentation at 1.33:1. These are both nearly square presentations. I’d use the edition’s format and aspect-ratio labels to make sense of the picture, especially if I was comparing the two discs in the same case.

    What’s in the U.S. combo

    The package contains one UHD disc plus two Blu-rays. The Blu-rays carry the film and supplements. Criterion lists the original mono soundtrack and a 2.0 surround option for the UHD edition. If you’re shopping for the commentary or other extras alone, check the features on your existing release first.

    Check the copy in front of you

    A regular Blu-ray player can use compatible Blu-rays from the set. An Ultra HD Blu-ray player is needed for the UHD disc. If an opened copy is listed used, ask for photos of all three disc labels. Imported editions may list different framing, supplements, and region information.

    Check the Amazon edition

    I may earn a commission if you buy through this Amazon link.

    Check the U.S. Criterion 4K combo on Amazon

    Sources

    Criterion’s Seven Samurai disc and framing specifications

  • The Red Shoes Criterion 4K and Blu-ray Guide

    If the restoration demonstration is the reason you’re shopping for The Red Shoes, check the supplement list on the exact edition before you buy. I’d choose the Criterion 4K combo for a compatible UHD setup or if I wanted both the 4K and Blu-ray versions in one case.

    What the two-disc set includes

    Criterion describes a 4K digital master from the 2009 restoration. The UHD disc carries the film in Dolby Vision HDR. The companion Blu-ray includes the film and extras. Among the listed extras are the restoration demonstration with Martin Scorsese and Ian Christie’s commentary, which incorporates interviews with people involved in the film.

    What I’d look for in a used listing

    The case should identify The Criterion Collection and explicitly say 4K UHD + Blu-ray if you want the combo. Ask for a picture of both disc labels when a listing mostly shows the cover. If you are mainly after the supplements and own a regular Blu-ray player, choose a Blu-ray edition that lists the extras you want.

    Check the Amazon edition

    I may earn a commission if you buy through the Amazon link below.

    Check The Red Shoes Criterion 4K combo on Amazon

    Keep browsing

    How DVD, Blu-ray, and 4K UHD differ

    Sources

    Criterion’s restoration and disc information

  • WALL·E Criterion 4K vs. Disney 4K

    If I already owned Disney’s U.S. WALL·E 4K, I’d keep it if my main goal was to watch the movie in UHD. I’d consider the Criterion set for its added supplements or its Dolby Vision and HDR10+ options on compatible equipment.

    What changes with Criterion

    The 2020 Disney U.S. UHD release lists HDR10. Criterion’s U.S. set from 2022 lists a UHD disc with Dolby Vision and HDR10+ and two Blu-rays with the movie and extras. The Criterion release includes a program on Andrew Stanton’s influences and one on production designer Ralph Eggleston’s color scripts. If the production choices are what you want to see, those are the extras I’d look for first.

    How to avoid buying the wrong edition

    Check the exact listing option for The Criterion Collection if that’s the set you want. Both sets use the name WALL·E and both have a 4K disc. On an opened Criterion copy, ask for a photo showing all three discs. If you are buying for a standard Blu-ray player, confirm the companion Blu-ray is included.

    Check the Amazon edition

    I may earn a commission if you buy through the Amazon link below.

    Check the three-disc Criterion WALL·E on Amazon

    Keep browsing

    What Dolby Vision and HDR10 mean on a disc

    Sources

    Criterion’s WALL·E disc and supplement list

    2020 Disney U.S. 4K edition specifications

  • 4K Blu-ray Gifts for Movie Collectors

    The first thing I check when buying a movie as a gift is what the recipient plays discs on. A combo that includes 4K UHD and standard Blu-ray can cover either kind of Blu-ray setup, subject to the discs’ regions. I’d also ask which edition they already own if they’re a serious collector.

    For the stop-motion fan

    Guillermo del Toro’s Pinocchio on Criterion is the pick I’d give to someone who is always watching making-of features. The combo includes the UHD film and a Blu-ray with extras about the production and animation. Select the 2022 Guillermo del Toro film so you land on the right Pinocchio.

    For a comfort-movie shelf

    I’d choose The Princess Bride on Criterion for someone who wants an edition that also looks good on the shelf. Check for the 2023 UHD combo with the clothbound packaging and the companion Blu-ray if that’s the format you intend to give.

    For the adventure or SteelBook collector

    The U.S. National Treasure SteelBook packages the original 2004 film on UHD and Blu-ray. I’d choose this when the case is part of the present. If you buy it used, check that both discs are included and treat the digital code as optional unless its status is clear.

    Check the Amazon listings

    I may earn a commission if you buy through the Amazon links below.

    Find the Pinocchio Criterion 4K combo on Amazon

    Find The Princess Bride Criterion 4K combo on Amazon

    Find the National Treasure 4K SteelBook on Amazon

    Sources

    Criterion’s Pinocchio disc details

    Criterion Forum’s Princess Bride edition details

    Disney’s National Treasure release details

  • The Piano Criterion 4K Edition and Extras

    For The Piano, I’d decide whether I wanted Jane Campion’s commentary and interviews, or the UHD presentation as well. Criterion offers the film on Blu-ray and in a 4K UHD + Blu-ray combo, so that decision can save you from buying more discs than you need.

    What’s inside the 4K set

    The UHD presents the restored film in Dolby Vision. Campion and cinematographer Stuart Dryburgh supervised and approved the restored 4K transfer. The included Blu-ray has the film and the supplements, which include commentary from Campion and producer Jan Chapman and a conversation with film critic Amy Taubin.

    Jane Campion’s The Piano Criterion cover artwork over a shoreline background.
    The Piano 4K graphic from my Pinterest series.

    A disc choice for film students and collectors

    If you’re collecting Campion’s work for the production context, use the supplement list to decide. Criterion includes interviews with Dryburgh, production designer Andrew McAlpine, and Māori adviser Waihoroi Shortland. If you care about accessibility or dialogue details, also check the publisher’s list of subtitle options before choosing between an older release and this one.

    What I’d check in the listing

    Select the exact Criterion format you need. A retailer may use “4K restoration” when describing an HD Blu-ray as well. Look for the UHD format explicitly if you want the two-disc combo. For a used set, ask which discs are present if only the outer case is pictured.

    Sources

    Compare both Criterion formats for The Piano

  • Marie Antoinette Criterion 4K vs. Blu-ray

    For Sofia Coppola’s Marie Antoinette, I’d choose the Criterion Blu-ray if my main reason for upgrading was the filmmaker and cast supplements and I only had a standard Blu-ray player. I’d choose the 4K combo if I also wanted the Dolby Vision version on a compatible setup.

    What Criterion added

    Coppola and cinematographer Lance Acord supervised and approved the new restoration. Criterion lists a Coppola interview, selected-scene commentary featuring Kirsten Dunst, and a program with Acord, production designer KK Barrett, and costume designer Milena Canonero. If you’re curious about how the look of the film came together, that production program is the extra I’d look for first.

    Which listing matches your player

    The U.S. 4K combo contains a UHD disc and a Blu-ray with the movie and extras. The standalone Blu-ray is a separate edition. Check for Criterion and “4K UHD + Blu-ray” in the exact variant you select if you want the combo. Its U.S. barcode is 715515344012. A retailer may list older DVDs and Blu-rays alongside the current Criterion releases.

    Sources

    See both formats and the extras at Criterion

    U.S. combo barcode and format