If I already had Kino Lorber’s U.S. 4K of The Silence of the Lambs, I’d consider Criterion mainly for its supplements. Both labels list Dolby Vision on their respective UHD releases, so I’d look at which commentary and interviews I want before deciding to buy the movie again.
The three-disc Criterion edition
Criterion’s 2026 U.S. combo includes one UHD disc and two Blu-rays. The label lists a 1994 commentary with Jonathan Demme, Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins, Ted Tally, and John Douglas, plus a later interview with Demme and Foster. For someone who collects the filmmakers’ audio commentaries, the listed 1994 track is a detail worth checking.

The two-disc Kino Lorber edition
Kino’s 30th-anniversary set includes the UHD and a Blu-ray. Its supplement list includes the original 1991 making-of featurette. Before upgrading, compare the two publishers’ actual supplement lists with the edition you already own and check which extras you’re likely to watch.
Pick the label on the listing
Select the U.S. Criterion 4K or Kino Lorber 4K by label and disc count. The same film artwork can show up with DVD, Blu-ray, UHD, and imported formats. I’d confirm the format in the selected option before ordering.
Check the Amazon edition
I may earn a commission if you buy through this Amazon link.
Check the 2026 Criterion three-disc 4K combo on Amazon