Category: Criterion and Boutique

Edition comparisons for Criterion and boutique-label films.

  • The Princess Bride Criterion 4K Edition and Booklet

    If I were buying The Princess Bride as a gift for a collector, I’d ask whether they want the movie in 4K, the Criterion supplements, or simply a copy for family movie night. The 2023 Criterion combo can serve all three, but it helps to know what the recipient already owns.

    What’s in the Criterion 4K release

    The set includes a Dolby Vision UHD disc and a standard Blu-ray. The supplements include the earlier commentary with Rob Reiner and William Goldman, among others. This edition also has an illustrated clothbound book with an essay and an excerpt from Goldman’s book. That format is worth checking if the buyer cares about the shelf presentation.

    Purple and gold Princess Bride Criterion artwork on a light linen couch.
    Illustration of the Criterion book-style package from my Pinterest series.

    How I’d shop for a used copy

    Check for two discs, ask for a picture of the book and holder, and look for wear around the spine and corners. If you only want the commentary and already own a Criterion Blu-ray, check that copy’s extras before buying again. If you’re gifting the combo to someone with a compatible standard Blu-ray player, they can still use the Blu-ray.

    Check the Amazon listing

    I may earn a commission if you buy through the Amazon links below.

    See the 2023 Criterion 4K set on Amazon

    Sources

    Criterion Forum’s release and supplement listing

    HD Report’s edition announcement

  • Guillermo del Toro’s Pinocchio on Criterion 4K

    For someone who likes seeing how stop-motion movies are made, the disc I’d check first is the Blu-ray in Criterion’s Guillermo del Toro’s Pinocchio set. It’s where Criterion puts the film and its supplements in the 4K combo. Choose the UHD combo if you also want the Dolby Vision presentation on a compatible setup.

    Three extras to look for

    Handcarved Cinema features people involved in making the film, including members of the puppet and animation teams. Directing Stop-Motion features directors Guillermo del Toro and Mark Gustafson. Criterion also includes a program about the animation rules used during production. Those extras give this release a clear reason to sit alongside other stop-motion titles.

    Guillermo del Toro’s Pinocchio Criterion cover in a blue and gold movie-night graphic.
    Pinocchio 4K graphic from my Pinterest series.

    Check the version before you buy

    Search for the full director’s name and the year 2022 if a result simply says Pinocchio. Criterion offers a 4K UHD + Blu-ray combo and a Blu-ray edition. If the only player in your setup is a standard Blu-ray player, the single-format Blu-ray is the option I’d price-check first. The combo makes sense if you want the UHD disc now or are planning a player upgrade.

    Check the Amazon listings

    I may earn a commission if you buy through the Amazon links below.

    See the Criterion 4K combo on Amazon

    See the Criterion Blu-ray on Amazon

    Sources

    Criterion’s Pinocchio edition and supplement list

  • Mulholland Dr. Criterion 4K UHD Edition Guide

    For David Lynch’s Mulholland Dr., I’d buy the Criterion 4K combo if I wanted the UHD presentation and already had a compatible player. If I were shopping for the interviews and only used a standard Blu-ray player, I’d compare the price of a Blu-ray edition first.

    What Criterion puts in the combo

    Criterion lists a Dolby Vision UHD disc and a separate Blu-ray with the film and supplements. Lynch and cinematographer Peter Deming supervised the 4K restoration for the UHD presentation. Criterion lists interviews with Lynch, Deming, and cast and crew, plus a deleted scene. The included Blu-ray gives you a disc to use on compatible HD equipment.

    Mulholland Dr. Criterion 4K cover artwork against a blue nighttime cityscape.
    Mulholland Dr. 4K graphic from my Pinterest series.

    Why the format line matters

    Amazon and secondhand listings can group several releases of the same movie. Look for “The Criterion Collection” and “4K UHD” on the specific version you select. A Blu-ray with Criterion branding is a different format choice. For an opened combo, check for both discs when the seller’s photos show the case.

    When I’d keep the copy I have

    If I already owned a Blu-ray and felt happy with it, I’d wait until I wanted the restoration on UHD or was getting a new player. The decision is easier when I know what I want to get out of the upgrade.

    Check the Amazon listing

    I may earn a commission if you buy through the Amazon links below.

    See the Criterion 4K UHD combo on Amazon

    Sources

    Criterion’s Mulholland Dr. release details

  • After Hours Criterion 4K vs. Blu-ray

    I’d choose the Criterion Blu-ray of After Hours (1985) for a standard Blu-ray player. If you own a 4K UHD player or plan to get one, the 4K combo gives you the UHD disc and a regular Blu-ray in the same case.

    Where the extras are

    Both editions use the restoration approved by editor Thelma Schoonmaker. The combo’s UHD disc presents the film in Dolby Vision HDR. The included Blu-ray carries the film and extras, including the Scorsese and Fran Lebowitz conversation, the commentary, and deleted scenes.

    After Hours Criterion cover artwork framed by a neon city scene.
    After Hours 4K graphic from my Pinterest series.

    Already own the Criterion Blu-ray? I’d keep it if you’re happy with the picture and mainly want the extras. Check your player and TV for Dolby Vision if that’s the upgrade you’re after.

    How to spot the right listing

    “4K restoration” describes the work done on the film. If you want to play a native 4K disc, look for the “4K UHD + Blu-ray” format on the listing and case. For U.S. copies, the standalone Blu-ray barcode is 715515285513. The 4K combo is 715515285414.

    Check the Amazon listings

    I may earn a commission if you buy through the Amazon links below.

    See the Criterion Blu-ray on Amazon

    See the Criterion 4K UHD combo on Amazon

    Release details and supplements from The Criterion Collection.

    Still deciding on a 4K player? Compare the Panasonic UB420 and UB820.