If I were buying The Princess Bride as a gift for a collector, I’d ask whether they want the movie in 4K, the Criterion supplements, or simply a copy for family movie night. The 2023 Criterion combo can serve all three, but it helps to know what the recipient already owns.
What’s in the Criterion 4K release
The set includes a Dolby Vision UHD disc and a standard Blu-ray. The supplements include the earlier commentary with Rob Reiner and William Goldman, among others. This edition also has an illustrated clothbound book with an essay and an excerpt from Goldman’s book. That format is worth checking if the buyer cares about the shelf presentation.

How I’d shop for a used copy
Check for two discs, ask for a picture of the book and holder, and look for wear around the spine and corners. If you only want the commentary and already own a Criterion Blu-ray, check that copy’s extras before buying again. If you’re gifting the combo to someone with a compatible standard Blu-ray player, they can still use the Blu-ray.
Check the Amazon listing
I may earn a commission if you buy through the Amazon links below.
See the 2023 Criterion 4K set on Amazon


