Out of print usually applies to a specific edition. Before paying extra for a DVD or Blu-ray marked OOP, I’d identify the label, format, and barcode. The movie could still be available in another edition that has the version or supplements you want.
Check whether you want the movie or this pressing
Start with the back cover and disc label. If a slipcover, commentary, or specific cut matters to you, ask whether it comes with the copy being sold. Publisher catalogs help you check whether a title is listed as out of print and whether other versions exist.
Compare completed sales for the same edition
Search the barcode or exact edition name and compare completed sales with the same format and condition. Factor in shipping and check whether the prices are for sealed copies, complete used copies, or loose discs. An active listing’s asking price tells you what someone hopes to get.
When I’d pay the premium
I’d pay extra when the exact copy has a feature I want and recent sales support the price. If I mainly want the movie for a first watch, I’d compare another release before paying more for a case or insert.
Browse the current Side Quest eBay listings