Tolkien’s Illustrated Lord of the Rings vs. the Art Book | Which Hardcover?

Buy The Lord of the Rings Illustrated by the Author if you want the complete novel with J.R.R. Tolkien’s drawings alongside the story. Buy The Art of The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien if you already have a reading copy and want to see more of his maps, sketches, and working drawings.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The two U.S. hardcovers at a glance

Buying detailIllustrated by the Author novelThe Art of The Lord of the Rings
What you getComplete novel in one hardcoverA companion volume of artwork and editorial commentary
What’s inside30 color illustrations, maps and sketches by Tolkien, plus two removable foldout maps by Christopher TolkienMore than 180 images, including working maps, sketches and finished drawings, with context from Wayne G. Hammond and Christina Scull
U.S. hardcover ISBN97803586530359780544636347

Which hardcover makes the better gift?

For someone reading the story for the first time, pick the illustrated novel. It follows the full story from the Shire through the end of The Return of the King in one volume. If you’re buying it used, ask whether both removable foldout maps are still included.

For someone who has read the series and already loves their copy, pick the art book. The working sketches are the reason to buy it. They let you see how Tolkien tried out maps, lettering and details while writing the story. The editors’ notes explain where the pieces fit.

How to tell Tolkien’s art from the Alan Lee edition

The Alan Lee illustrated box set is a separate reading edition with Lee’s artwork. If you want Tolkien’s own drawings, match the hardcover ISBN and look for Illustrated by the Author on the novel or The Art of on the companion volume.

Edition details are listed by the MIT Press Bookstore for the novel and Bookshop.org for the art book.