Which Muppet Christmas Carol DVD Has “When Love Is Gone”?

For a physical copy of The Muppet Christmas Carol with “When Love Is Gone,” buy Kermit’s 50th Anniversary Edition DVD from 2005 and choose the fullscreen version in the menu. The same DVD also plays the shorter theatrical cut in widescreen. Disney’s U.S. Special Edition Blu-ray plays that theatrical cut.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Which edition should you buy?

U.S. discMovie versionBuy it if…
2005 Kermit’s 50th Anniversary DVDFullscreen extended cut with the song, plus a widescreen theatrical cutYou remember Belle’s scene and want it to play as part of the movie.
Disney Special Edition Blu-ray (2015 repackage)Widescreen theatrical cutYou prefer the HD presentation and are happy with the theatrical edit.

How to spot the right DVD in a listing

Look for Kermit’s 50th Anniversary Edition on the cover and UPC 786936286991 on the back. If the seller uses a stock image, ask for a photo of the actual case and disc. The 2005 release puts both versions on one DVD, so there’s no separate disc to look for.

At the menu, choose Fullscreen. On a modern widescreen TV, that 4:3 presentation usually leaves black bars down both sides. That’s the trade-off for watching the song in the film on this DVD. The “50th” branding refers to Kermit’s anniversary.

What if you want widescreen with the song?

Look for The Muppet Christmas Carol: Uncut Version under the film’s Extras on Disney+ where available. The restored streaming cut puts the song back into the widescreen movie. The standard listing may open the theatrical version first.

Disc details are documented by the Free Library of Philadelphia and DVDizzy’s Blu-ray review. The Disney+ version guide shows where the uncut movie was added.

For another holiday shelf pick, see which Christmas Vacation 4K disc has the extras.

Comments

One response to “Which Muppet Christmas Carol DVD Has “When Love Is Gone”?”

  1. […] For another Christmas watch with edition differences, see which Muppet Christmas Carol DVD has Belle’s song. […]